Civil Society and the quest for electoral justice in Malawi

By Billy Mayaya* PhD
When one casts a critical eye on Malawi’s nascent democracy, one cannot do so without assessing the role of Civil Society in the state of play. The concerns about the political leadership gaps, the checks and balances among the executive, the judiciary and the legislature also point to questions about the relevance of civil society in the development of a democratic state in Malawi. In this brief article, I attempt to outline the key issues that propelled.
Context
While elections are the hallmark of every democratic society, Malawi’s young history with elections has been anything but satisfactory. The use of the words “free” and “fair” have been variously contested. As opposed to being a tool for peacefully selecting the country’s leadership, it has brought another layer of disputation in Malawi. The lowest moment of these sad developments were the 2019 Tripartite Elections. The adoption of the Constitution of Malawi in 1995 aimed to change the approach to governance and views about democracy. Elections under the Constitution are expected to be free, peaceful and credible.
Delivering on this constitutional requirement is the responsibility of several institutions. All Malawians too have a role to play. In the scheme of implementation, the Judiciary plays a part both at the tail end of the process as well as through occasional interventions throughout the electoral cycle. It, however, has the principal responsibility of addressing disputes that arise from elections.
As the build up to the elections grew, the Judiciary was alive to the confidence crisis that Malawi Electoral Commission MEC as an institution faced in the eyes of the Malawian people as it pertained to electoral disputes. The May 2019 Elections which were eventually annulled on February 3 2020 point to much of the unfinished business and many unfulfilled promises, including stalled electoral reforms, limited media pluralism, and a lack of political will to move from the rhetoric of transparency to its reality. It is in this context that civil society, through the Human Rights Defenders Coalition (HRDC) has persistently worked towards incremental electoral justice.
Demands for accountability
Accountability in elections is a broad term underpinned by many different understandings and applications. From a human rights standpoint, electoral justice is often juxtaposed with other terms, such as responsibility to ensure a free, fair and accessible process, the duties, or obligations of the Malawi Electoral Commission (MEC) as arbiter of the polls. Electoral justice as a concept serves similar purposes as do responsibility (and liability), including protecting the rule of law, and paving the way for democracy consolidation.
But it is also essential to the protection of democratic values (Curtin and Nollkaemper 2005: 9) and key to validating the status of delegated public power. elected representatives generally dislike being held accountable. Yet they often have reasons to submit to accountability mechanisms. In a democratic or pluralistic system, electoral justice is essential to maintaining public confidence. Sadly, in Malawi’s nascent democracy, power holders have sought to avoid accountability in order to advance an electoral agenda that suggests impunity at all levels.
Vertical and horizontal accountability
Through the historic Constitutional Court ruling, politicians have been made accountable through a wide range of measures: judicial mechanisms such as constitutional and legal courts, political means by way of voters and elections, and through political parties, the media, and Civil Society: Electoral justice is an essential characteristic of democratic government in that it refers to the organization of public power in a democratic fashion through avenues such as organized Civil Society, that is, in a way that makes the government responsive to the people. It goes hand in hand with good governance, which concerns the exercise of public power in the pursuit of the public good and justice for all.
Whichever definition of electoral justice is adopted, there are a number of characteristics beyond discussion. It requires duty bearers and duty holders, a reporting process, a common understanding of what is expected in a election dynamic on or against, and consequences for the actions. To be made operational, electoral justice thus requires understanding who is accountable, to whom, for what, how and understanding the consequences for breach of the electoral contract.
MEC accountability
When applied to elections in Malawi, this operational definition thus becomes: MEC and its officials are accountable to the people of Malawi for abiding by the laws and the constitution and delivering free, fair and credible elections in the public interest. Additional MEC as an elections management body is held accountable through scrutiny exercised by the parliament, the public, civil society, and the media. In terms of any breach, the ultimate consequence of lack of accountability (perceived or real) may be legal.
Elections require an intense investment of human, logistical and organizational resources. This is particularly true in countries like Malawi transitioning to democracy, where the fundamental institutions responsible for administering elections may have been fragile. While it is natural for aspiring democracies to focus on electoral operations related to election day, building a sustainable electoral democracy involves much broader efforts.
Democracy building
Civil Society through HRDC believes that creating an environment for electoral justice is an essential priority in the beginning of Malawi’s democracy-building process. Without an electoral justice system in place, repressive laws or unaddressed electoral crime, violations or irregularities may result in elections that lack credibility with key stakeholders.
This in turn may lead to a step backwards on the path to democracy and in some instances lead to the ignition of latent conflict Electoral justice concerns more than the resolution of electoral disputes related to election day, although that is an important component. It also involves the means and mechanisms for (a) ensuring that each action, procedure and decision related to the electoral process; and (b) for protecting or restoring the enjoyment of electoral rights are in line with the law.
Way forward
Civil Society believes that developing an appropriate electoral legal framework is an important early step. Laws at all levels should comply with international standards, which countries transitioning to democracy should adopt as national obligations. It is critical that the legal framework is clear, comprehensive, and designed to be enforced equally on all.
To the extent possible, lawmakers should try to ensure that a complete electoral legal framework, including a framework governing the role of institutions, is in place at a sufficiently early point before election day so that all stakeholders have an opportunity to familiarize themselves with it. The process of developing a legal framework should include the opportunity for input from all key stakeholders to promote public and other stakeholder confidence in the law.
To gain stakeholder confidence, Civil Society is of the opinion electoral justice should be independent, impartial, professional and inclusive. Independence should include both protections for individual officials from retaliation and institutional independence from interference by other branches of government. Impartiality may not always be attainable in a politically polarized setting, so institutions may opt instead for politically ‘balanced’ judicial panels or boards.
Professionalism is a key, and often underrated, characteristic of an effective electoral justice institution. MEC will lose credibility if its staff are discourteous and its operations are disorganized. Ensuring the inclusion of women and minority groups is particularly important because it helps ensure that the views of traditionally under-represented groups are considered, which in turn promotes institutional legitimacy with these groups. Inclusivity also encompasses the accessibility of electoral justice institutions to all persons, regardless of gender, native language, disability, or other statuses that in some instances may make these institutions difficult or impossible to access.

Decision-makers such as MEC should focus on reducing the likelihood of electoral injustice occurring again, particularly during the electoral stage of the electoral cycle. This can be accomplished by establishing and enforcing electoral laws and procedures designed to minimize the opportunity for crime, other misconduct, or irregularities. Decision-makers should also continuously re-evaluate all aspects of MEC operations to ensure its maximum efficiency and effectiveness. As Malawi develops and consolidates democracy and its democratic institutions, it may be necessary to reconsider and perhaps modify the roles, responsibilities, and jurisdictions of electoral justice institutions to maximize their ability to address new risks of electoral injustice as they emerge.
Conclusion
Finally, it is essential that electoral justice works to gain and maintain public and other key stakeholder confidence in order to develop the legitimacy necessary to operate effectively in a democratic society. Trust can be strengthened through the implementation of measures to promote institutional transparency and accountability. Both civic voter and human rights education are essential to building trust.
An electorate educated on both how MEC functions and its importance as the guarantor of electoral justice will become a more active participant in asserting fundamental rights and identifying and reporting incidents of election-related misconduct.
* Mayaya is a regular contributor to The Lamp magazine
buy generic 100mg viagra online generic viagra best place to buy viagra online
viagra no prescription buy sildenafil canadian pharmacy viagra
cialis ingredient cheap cialis cialis generic availability
viagra generic generic viagra viagra pill
best ed drugs pumps for ed ed causes and treatment
drug pharmacy male erection pills best ed treatment
viagra price canadian pharmacy viagra viagra 100mg
cheap viagra 100mg buy viagra from canada viagra without a doctor prescription canada
viagra price cheap viagra 100mg viagra
cheap viagra 100mg viagra online pharmacy viagra
cat antibiotics without pet prescription generic viagra dysfunction erectile
non prescription ed pills ED Pills ed meds online
what is the best ed pill cheap ed pills solutions for ed
aspirin and ed generic ed pills buy prescription drugs online without
ed drugs online from canada ED Pills cheap erectile dysfunction pill
pump for ed canadian online drugs new ed drugs
safe alternatives to viagra and cialis tadalafil coffee with cialis
purchasing cialis on the internet cheap cialis can you have multiple orgasms with cialis
google viagra dosage recommendations ed pills online pharmacy what are ed drugs
male dysfunction canada ed drugs best non prescription ed pills
best prices on dapoxetine https://salemeds24.wixsite.com/dapoxetine
hydroxychloroquine countries otc https://hydroxychloroquine.webbfenix.com/
drugs from india canadian pharmacy
cheap generic sildenafil sildenafil generic
buy sildenafil online buy sildenafil online
buy tadalafil generic tadalafil
cost of vidalista 5mg with insurance https://vidalista.mlsmalta.com/
is hydroxychloroquine expensive https://hydroxychloroquine.mlsmalta.com/
buy sildenafil online buy sildenafil online
ivermectin lice oral https://ivermectin.mlsmalta.com/
women’s silagra https://silagra.buszcentrum.com/
cephalexin and eliquis interaction https://keflex.webbfenix.com/
can humans use ivermectin https://ivermectin.webbfenix.com/
common side effects of viagra http://droga5.net/
generic dapoxetine not as good as regular https://dapoxetine.confrancisyalgomas.com/
generic viagra india buy viagra viagra without a doctor prescription
drugs and medications canadian pharmacy viagra overcoming ed
male ed pills best online canadian pharmacy the best ed pills
cialis coupon code cialis online viagra vs cialis
cialis in canada cheap cialis cialis 20 mg
tadalafil 5mg best price https://wisig.org/
what is vidalista used for https://vidalista40mg.mlsmalta.com/
what is the best ed pill canadian pharmacy online ed meds
compare ed drugs generic viagra without a doctor prescription real viagra without a doctor prescription usa
cheap erectile dysfunction Zithromax online online ed medications
buy viagra online usa viagra for sale viagra from canada
nolvadex for sale pct https://tamoxifen.mrdgeography.com/
male dysfunction pills canadian online pharmacy ed meds
generic viagra viagra sale online viagra
viagra otc viagra cost walmart viagra
walgreens price for cialis 20mg cialis generic cialis 100 mg lowest price
ed drug prices cheap Amoxil male ed drugs
viagra generic viagra coupons 75% off buy viagra online
online prescription refills https://medpills.bee-rich.com/
how to make homemade dapoxetine https://ddapoxetine.com/
amstyles.com https://amstyles.com/
can ed be cured: prescription without a doctor’s prescription best male enhancement
viagra without a prescription: prescription drugs without doctor approval prescription without a doctor’s prescription
fish antibiotics doxycycline http://doxycycline.zolftgenwell.org/
cheapest viagra online is there a generic for viagra where can i buy viagra over the counter
buy cheap generic zithromax zithromax pill zithromax for sale cheap
male erection canadian pharmacy online best online drugstore
zithromax antibiotic without prescription zithromax online usa zithromax pill
zithromax coupon zithromax 500mg price in india generic zithromax india
can you have multiple orgasms with cialis cialis without doctor prescription prices of cialis
is generic cialis safe prices of cialis cialis 20 mg
cialis tadalafil vs viagra https://tadalafil.cleckleyfloors.com/
roman viagra generic viagra 100mg viagra without a doctor prescription
viagra price comparison
generic viagra india viagra for sale viagra 100mg price
cheap viagra 100mg
chloroquine testing in france https://hydroxychloroquinee.com/
drugs similar to remdesivir https://hydroxychloroquine.wisig.org/
Doxycycline antibiotics cheap Flagyl viagra without doctor prescription
best over the counter ed pills online pharmacies without an rx pharmacies not requiring a prescription
buy prescription drugs without doctor men’s ed pills erectile dysfunction pills
amox k 875 125 buy antibiotics shots for ed
online medication ed meds online without doctor prescription men’s ed pills
Amoxil buy Flagyl ed medications comparison
ed pills that work quickly canadian pharmacy cialis best rated canadian pharmacies
buy ed drugs online canadian online pharmacy prescription drugs
mens erection pills approved canadian online pharmacies canada drugs online
walmart viagra generic viagra how to buy viagra
buy cialis online no prescription https://www.lm360.us/
ed therapy canadian drugs mens erections
online canadian drugstore canadian pharmacies shipping to usa canada drugs
ed pharmacy medication for ed dysfunction non prescription erection pills
cialis prices 20mg cialis liquid cialis
doctor services online https://edmeds.buszcentrum.com/
brand cialis vs generic cialis https://cialzi.com/
zhivnncr viagra viagra cialis
amazon viagra https://cheapvgr100.online/ ppqnbakn
pnirsygi generic viagra generic viagra walmart
buy bactrim online essential oils antibiotic medicine amoxicillin 500
generic valtrex canada where to buy acyclovir cream acyclovir over the counter
where can i buy benadryl tablets zyrtec-d 24 hour where can i order periactin online
amoxicillin without a doctors prescription antibiotic resistance marina warner amoxicillin 875 125 mg tab
benadryl 25 mg tablet cost benadryl cream 45 zyrtec
order acyclovir online where to buy acyclovir online can you buy famvir
benadryl brand name in india zyrtec uk buy allegra 20 mg
plaquenil toxicity oct https://hydroxychloroquine.wisig.org/
eosgpcoc switching from tamsulosin to cialis http://cialisirt.online/ how to take cialis
ozyhuvbq what are the side effects of cialis http://cialisirt.online/ the effects of cialis on women
rtosccdg non prescription viagra http://viagrastm.online/ viagra without a doctor prescription canada
bcozspfx generic viagra http://viagrastm.com/ online viagra
bypwndpw where to buy viagra online http://viagrastm.com/ over the counter viagra cvs
vidalista price walmart http://viidalista.co/
buy drug online https://canadianpharmacyvikky.com ed clinics
impotence pills https://canadianpharmacyvikky.com non prescription ed pills
sildenafil by teva http://cavalrymenforromney.com/
Sexy pictures each day
http://pornofreeanoal.nakedbbwphoto.fetlifeblog.com/?zaria
black porn heather free porn t n a negligee porn video anime katara porn brother bangs new sister porn
40 mg of prednisone daily https://bvsinfotech.com/
Как упоминалось, для работы с Гидрой необходимо использовать браузер Тор. Но кроме того, необходимо войти на необходимый вебсайт, не угодив к жуликам, каковых достаточно много. Потому, плюсом от нас, у вас будет hydra сайт.
I am also writing to make you know what a incredible encounter my friend’s girl gained reading through your web page. She learned plenty of pieces, which include what it’s like to possess an amazing helping mood to let other folks smoothly know just exactly several multifaceted subject matter. You truly exceeded our own expectations. Thank you for offering these necessary, safe, explanatory and even fun tips about this topic to Julie.
cialis 5mg price comparison http://cealis1.com/
erectile dysfunction pills treatment for erectile dysfunction pharmacy prices
best drugstore bb cream pharmacy rx one dollar store drug test
24 hr pharmacy http://pharmacy-onlineasxs.com/ board of pharmacy
rx pharmacy e d pharmacy drugstore online
best ed pills that work
https://canadarx24.com/
best medicine for ed
ed online pharmacy
https://canadarx24.com/
ed doctor
24 hr pharmacy near me erection pills erectile dysfunction
canada drugs online pharmacy online drugstore best drugstore moisturizer
us pharmacy mexican pharmacy drug store
pharmacies peoples pharmacy mexican pharmacy
erection pills online ahthszoc cheap levitra shots for ed
mexican pharmacy without prescription mzkofusm levitra generic legal to buy prescription drugs without prescription
cialis 20mg cialis coupon smypogmi cialis free trial
interactions for cialis cialis online hdjcpsyo generic cialis without prescription
taking l-citrulline and cialis together buy cialis avthihpf where to get cialis sample
how to get viagra without a doctor baghcrun buy viagra online online pharmacy viagra